Quotation Vranes, Erich. 2006. The Definition of ‘Norm Conflict’ in International Law and Legal Theory (EJIL, Oxford University Press). European Journal of International Law 17 (2): 395-418.


RIS


BibTeX

Abstract

This article argues that the narrow definition of conflict apparently prevailing in international law doctrine and recent WTO rulings is inappropriate in terms of legal theory and in view of the fundamental structures of the international legal order. The problem with this strict definition is that it does not recognize that a permissive norm may conflict with a prescriptive norm. In this perspective, established conflict rules such as the lex posterior and lex specialis principles cannot be applied in order to determine whether a permissive norm (such as a WTO exception or an MEA permission to restrict trade) actually constitutes the lex posterior or the lex specialis which was meant to prevail by the contracting parties. Further problems in recent academic writings and WTO jurisprudence have been caused by an insufficient distinction between norms of conduct and norms establishing competences. This paper therefore shows that an adequate definition has to encompass incompatibilities between prescriptive norms as well as permissive norms and concludes that an appropriate definition should rely on the ‘test of violation’ first introduced by Kelsen.

Tags

Press 'enter' for creating the tag

Publication's profile

Status of publication Published
Affiliation WU
Type of publication Journal article
Journal European Journal of International Law
Citation Index SSCI
Language English
Title The Definition of ‘Norm Conflict’ in International Law and Legal Theory (EJIL, Oxford University Press)
Volume 17
Number 2
Year 2006
Page from 395
Page to 418
Reviewed? Y

Associations

Projects
Trade and the Environment - Fundamental Issues in International and WTO Law
People
Vranes, Erich (Details)
Organization
Europainstitut (Nf. Griller) (Former organization)
Research areas (ÖSTAT Classification 'Statistik Austria')
5211 International relations (Details)
5235 International law (Details)
5251 Theory of law (Details)
Google Scholar: Search